What a session is like?
Hypnosis as a loss of control
Welcome to the second in our 5 Myths of Hypnosis series!
Here I’m aiming to provide some clarity amongst the muddy marketplace of hypnosis courses – to try to cut through the hype, get the pop out of the psychology, separate the science from the superstition, and see what the research says.
So join me as we dive into the second myth: hypnosis as a loss of control.
As a concept, this actually underpins a lot of the widely-held misconceptions about hypnosis: hypnosis as trance, as sleep, as amnesia, as mind control, etc.
For most people, the idea that a powerful hypnotist can ‘take control’ of your mind, implant ideas deep in your unconscious and make you do what they want is both very scary, and perhaps secretly very appealing for some… I mean, when did you last feel in control of your mind? 😉
This myth is about power play. Bigging up the power of the therapist and utterly reducing the power and agency of the subject or client. Some people do come for hypnotherapy because they hold the idea “I want my mind to be taken over and reprogrammed!”. In my experience, many of these clients do not do well in therapy, even if the therapist is willing to play along with this idea. For the majority of potential clients, however, the idea that someone will take over the mind is distinctly worrying, and may even preclude them looking at hypnotherapy as a solution to their problems.
But, if you look at the research, the idea of hypnotic subject ‘losing control of their mind’ is not supported anywhere, at all!
So, let’s look at the reasons why this myth exists, and how it impacts what happens in the therapy room.
‘Losing control’: hypnosis on stage
Stage hypnosis has been a popular form of entertainment for centuries – and is founded on the very idea that the subject loses control of their will at the hands of the ‘powerful hypnotist’.
Since the early 19th Century, the hypnotist showmen (or conmen!) claimed to hold the ‘telepathic powers’ to control the strange behaviour and stunts of the hypnotic subject. But this idea of the hypnotic subject as a passive recipient of the powerful suggestions of the hypnotist finds its roots in the early predecessor of hypnosis: Mesmerism. Franz Mesmer believed he was channelling real magnet energy into his patients, which brought about a “healing crisis” from which they arose seeming “healed”.
As Mesmerism gave way to Hypnosis the appearance and underlying notion of the power of “the healer” (the hypnotist) remained, transferring not magnet energy but willpower and ideas.
This idea still lingers and fascinates today – evident with entertainers like Derren Brown captivating Channel 4 audiences with his ‘stunts’.
Although Derren Brown often shares accurate information on psychology and hypnosis, it often gets lost in the mix, because Brown isn’t primarily an educator – he’s an entertainer.
The concept of hypnosis as a loss of control is fantastic for the facade of a stage show, but fundamentally inaccurate in reality off-stage.
Experimental research debunks this ‘entertaining’ idea completely, with research showing that…
Subjects keep the ability to control their behaviour during hypnosis, to refuse to respond to suggestions, and to even oppose them. (1)
People can respond to suggestions with or without hypnosis: a formal hypnotic ‘induction’ is primarily to increase suggestibility to a small degree. (2, 3)
Hypnosis depends more on the efforts and abilities of the subject than on the ‘skills’ of the hypnotist. (3)
Not to mention that often stage hypnotists are happy to confess the deception of their shows. The famous stage hypnotist and magician from the 70s, The Amazing Kreskin, has written several books spilling the secret methods behind his stunts. (4)
So, there is clearly a huge difference between the education, discussion and research into hypnosis, and it’s entertainment value on stage or on-screen!
Self-hypnosis
Perhaps the most important concept contradicting this loss of control idea is self-hypnosis.
It fundamentally goes against the myth that the ‘power’ lies in the skill of the hypnotist – as the hypnotist is removed from the equation completely!
As you learn to focus your attention, give yourself positive suggestions and find yourself responding powerfully to them – and perhaps even discover that you can “learn” to do self-hypnosis and improve your response over time – you begin to see that hypnosis is more about the focus, motivation and abilities of the subject than “the master hypnotist”.
The self-hypnotising subject has complete control over their experience.
And can use that control to make positive, lasting change both inside and outside the therapy room.
Moreover, the transfer of the power, what we call “the locus of control”, from the powerful therapist to the empowered client is deeply therapeutic and enabling.
Hypnotisability
What follows from this, and is demonstrated in research, is that a subject’s hypnotisability – in terms of both hypnosis and self-hypnosis – is improved through the subject’s own choice to behave and think differently.
Research in at least five laboratories has shown that more than half of participants who are originally test as ‘low hypnotisability’ can – after positive attitudes about hypnosis are imagined and accepted – become ‘highly hypnotisable’. (4)
These positive attitudes include understanding hypnosis as a collaborative or self-directed psychological process.
So, ultimately, your hypnotisability can change when you reconsider misconceptions such as the loss of control – not to mention the others we’re discussing in this series!
This principle of collaboration – naturally opposed to any ‘loss of control’ principle – positions hypnotherapy within the field of legitimate psychotherapies.
So, if a person wants to engage in hypnosis, learns about it, and confidently participates in it – it will happen!
And it’s happening is entirely due to the control the subject hold in doing all of these things.
Complete control?
Hypnosis is therefore fundamentally NOT a loss of the subject’s control.
Unlike hypnotic ‘performances’ on stage – or screen – it isn’t induced by a powerful hypnotist, beholder of magic telepathic abilities to remove a person’s will…
Hypnosis ‘happens’ as the result of a collaborative or self-driven effort to relax and focus on suggested ideas. And imagine, experience, think-along-with with those ideas.
Now…. it’s not quite as simple as that.
There is an aspect of ‘loss of control’ that is true! The fundamental experience of hypnosis is that it seems involuntary, that you don’t seem to be doing it. We willingly focus our attention on the ideas suggested by the hypnotist and imagine them being true – and then begin to experience them happening all by themselves. Our eyelids close involuntarily, our arms get very heavy automatically, the other arm seems to get lighter and lighter and begin to float up…what is going on?!! Here we are not under the control of the hypnotist – rather we are responding to our imagination. Suggestions in hypnosis can be considered as “invitations to imagine” – as you focus and then imagine your body responding to those ideas (since every idea is actually a physiological event in the body.) And with positive motivation, trust, the expectancy of the hypnotic situation and our focused attention and imagination – those responses to imaginings can become extraordinarily and surprisingly powerful. It is true that we are allowing ourselves to flow along with the suggestions being given by the hypnotist – but we can stop that at any moment – so are not under their control.
As a client responds to the suggested ideas we, as a good hypnotherapist, begin to immediately suggest that they can now respond to their own, self-given suggestions – and so we immediately help develop a self-hypnosis responsive mindset.
So the partnership of giving and then responding to ideas are turned into an internal process the client can do with themselves. It’s a bit like dancing. You have to let go and feel the music to dance well. You can’t control each movement voluntarily (or your dancing will develop the sort of notoriety that is not desirable!)
In the same way, you let go and let yourself and feel and imagine and respond to the ideas being given.
And of course, just like with dancing, over control is a problem. If you are too self-controlling you can neither dance nor respond to hypnosis.
But if you expect the music or the hypnotist to do all the work then nothing happens!
So, I hope I’ve explained the balance between exerting and losing control in hypnosis well to you.
And hopefully debunked another popular myth!
In a similar way, YOU also have control: to learn about hypnosis, engage with the research, move against commonly-held misassumptions. And help others do the same.
You can click here to read about the first Myth in the series – Trance.
And click here to find out more about our Diploma in Cognitive Behavioural Hypnotherapy.
References:
- Lynne S. J., Rhue J. W., & Weekes. J. R. (1990). Hypnotic involuntariness: A social-cognitive analysis. Psychological Review, 97, 169-184
- Barber, T. X. (1969). Hypnosis: A Scientific Approach. South Orange, NJ: Power Publishers
- Hilgard, E. R. (1965). Hypnotic Susceptibility. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.
- See most famously: Kreskin (1991). Secrets of the Amazing Kreskin: The World’s Foremost Mentalist Reveals How You Can Expand Your Powers. 1st ed. Prometheus.
- Spanos, N. P. (1991). A sociocognitive approach to hypnosis. In S. J. Lynn and J. W. Rhue (Eds), Theories of hypnosis: Current models and perspectives (pp. 324-361). New York. Guildford Press
Photo by Youssef Naddam (Unsplash)
Hypnosis as ‘trance’
Welcome to the first in our Cutting through the Five Myths of Hypnosis series!
I want to share with you the most common myths and misconceptions about hypnosis – and why it’s so important to question them, look to the science and use more research-informed ways of talking about hypnosis.
I’m going to try and cut through the confusion in the field and bring some clarity.
Back in 2006 when I was trying to figure out what to do in terms of my career, someone suggested that training in hypnotherapy was the perfect solution.
A short, concise training (not a 4-year psychotherapy course) – quickly providing me with the ability to start working with people helping them change.
However, I was horrified! Hypnosis?! Hypnotherapy?!!
You’ve got to be kidding!!
At that point, for me, hypnosis and hypnotherapy seemed mystical and murky and too much of a magic show.
I associated it with stage hypnosis and people selling hyped-up personal development training (“Learn to influence others”, “the power of conversational hypnosis”, “rapid transformation in one session” etc).
However – when I looked into it a bit deeper, I saw there was a whole world of knowledge, discussion and research into hypnosis.
In fact, it is astonishing to me that these two “worlds” of hypnosis exist – the magical (credulous) vs the scientific (reasonable).
Although, I want to assure you that stripping away the myths is a fascinating journey that takes away none of the power of hypnosis – indeed, it actually helps us use it more powerfully and effectively.
I’m also greatly interested in our need for magic, mystery and wonder. It is a deep part of our human condition. Too often, however, we direct this at the wrong things and end up with unhelpful, superstitious beliefs.
So, I want to dispel the myths in order to uncover some wonderful truths about hypnosis!
You’ll probably agree that the marketplace for hypnotherapy training is a really confusing mix of grandiose claims, an incredible number of “world-famous” celebrity hypnotherapists and lots of people claiming to teach “the secrets” or to have studied with the “greatest hypnotherapist who ever lived”.
I’m passionate about cutting through the pop psychology and pseudoscience and educating people – both therapists and clients – in our research-based approach to hypnotherapy.
As the famous psychologist Professor Hans Eysenck stated, “Very few topics in the whole history of mankind can have given rise to so many absurdities, misunderstandings, and misconceptions” (1).
Over half a century later, this statement continues to ring true – perhaps even more so in an Internet-led era!
Let’s distill the truth from the hype, the science from the superstition.
We’re kicking the series off with a discussion of perhaps the most misleading term within hypnotherapy discourses – TRANCE.
The meaning of the term ‘trance’
Although not a ‘myth’ as such, the way it is used within popular psychology, stage hypnosis and many hypnotherapy schools and practitioners adds a sense of ‘mystery’ to hypnosis – and an aura of power and prestige to the hypnotist.
However, this clashes with the research evidence – and causes problems and confusion for both clients and therapists.
It’s interesting to see that the meaning of trance has changed over the decades. When hypnosis first started, with the work of James Braid around 1860, a ‘trance’ referred to a death-like coma state!
Whereas nowadays we might say “Oh, you can’t talk to Mark right now he’s in a trance watching Wimbledon.”
But this weakened use of the term, typically related to being deeply absorbed in a book or task, conflicts with the idea of being “put into a trance” by a hypnotist – an idea that tends to scare people away!
So which are we doing? Focusing their attention or putting them in a trance?
See the confusion?!!
I never talk about trance when I’m introducing clients to hypnosis. I don’t think it is at all helpful in a therapy setting.
I’ve trained over 1000 students in hypnosis – both in the UK and in China. I can tell you that those who cling to the idea of trance get stuck and confused.
If I start talking about trance, my clients will get nervous and questioning of their experience:
“Am in hypnosis yet?”
“Am I in a trance? Am I doing it right?”
“If I cough will I break the trance?”
OR
“What if I get stuck in a trance!?”
Can you see that the very idea of inducing a trance can generate a whole series of fears and thoughts – that prevent hypnosis from happening!
Every single student who had previously trained in a trance-based approach to hypnosis has come up and thanked me for showing them how hypnosis works, how simple and straightforward it actually is.
So if we don’t put clients into a trance – what is it that we do?
Good question!
I think hypnosis has a really simple definition: focused attention on a dominant idea.
And I tend to expand on that: focused “thinking-along-with” (feeling, imagining, experiencing) a series of ideas given by the therapist (or by themselves in self-hypnosis).
Let me try to explain and I hope you’ll see it really is very straightforward.
- As hypnotherapists, we help clients focus their attention on ideas and suggestions which they wish to experience and which will benefit them.
- As they get absorbed and pulled into that experience of focusing and thinking-along-with those ideas, they forget about the external world and get more and more absorbed.
- As they get focused and absorbed into those ideas and experiences in a way that daily life doesn’t usually allow them, this becomes a very vivid and completely undistracted experience.
- This unusually undistracted, concentrated experience leaves a significant impression, a latent trace, on their thinking, feeling and behaving… like new grooves in their mind.
So, in hypnosis, you are highly focused on the ideas being given by the hypnotherapist and you are thinking-along-with those ideas… and therefore having new vivid experiences which change the way you feel, think and behave after hypnosis.
That’s hypnosis!
(Notice we didn’t use the word ‘trance’ once!)
What does the research say about ‘trance’?
Firstly – in research hypnotised subjects do not describe their experience as ‘trance’ but as focused attention on suggested events (2). That’s pretty useful to know!
Secondly – Professor Clark Hull, the first scientific researcher to study hypnosis back in 1933, quickly discovered that when you gave the same suggestions (to relax and experience things) but did NOT “induce hypnosis” – the results were pretty similar.
Putting people into a “hypnotic trance” didn’t seem to really make much difference. It was the instructions and suggestions to experience things that made the difference. Not the “trance”. So, the whole idea of “hypnotic trance” lost the power explain the extraordinary experiences people had (3).
Thirdly – despite huge amounts of effort to try to find a physiological or neurological indicator of “the trance” – a way of measuring it – none has been found.
“Special state” researchers (who think hypnosis is a special state of consciousness) have never been able to find any physiological indicators of hypnosis (4).
Intense research continues to this day.
And NO-ONE has yet found the state of hypnosis.
That’s just a fact. Period.
So when a hypnotherapy training school tells you that they know the secrets to inducing a trance and how to tell if the client is in a trance… take those claims with a huge dose of salt!
But here’s the most important thing.
When we drop the idea of trance from hypnosis we make hypnosis less scary and much more accessible and acceptable.
Without ‘trance-y’ connotations, everyone becomes much more willing to try hypnosis, and include it in self-development programmes and stress management courses.
The second big win here is that when we get rid of the idea of trance and start talking about focused attention, motivation, imagination – we can integrate hypnosis into scientifically informed psychotherapies like Cognitive Behaviour Therapy or Acceptance and Commitment Therapy.
And that is hugely important. Because there is research showing that adding hypnosis to CBT actually improves the CBT (5). And that is exactly the approach you will learn on 21-day Diploma in Cognitive Behavioural Hypnotherapy.
The idea of trance is just one misconception enshrouding hypnosis and hypnotherapy.
I hope you see that by being a bit skeptical of ideas and concepts that are presented around hypnosis, by drawing on some of the research and being a little less “credulous”, we can have great confidence in the credibility of hypnosis. And be able to explain it to others easily and acceptably.
I hope you found this helpful.
And watch out for the next in the series, Myth no.2: Hypnosis as loss of control.
Click here to find out more about our Diploma in Cognitive Behavioural Hypnotherapy.
You can read more about trance in our other blog articles linked below:
———————————
References:
- Eysenck, H (1957) Sense and Nonsense in Psychology.
- McConkey, K. M. (1986). Opinions about hypnosis and self-hypnosis before and after hypnotic testing. International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis, 34.
- Nash, M., & Barnier, A. (2012). Oxford Handbook of Hypnosis (1st ed.).
- Steven Jay Lynn, Jean-Roch Laurence & Irving Kirsch (2015) Hypnosis, Suggestion, and Suggestibility: An Integrative Model, American Journal of Clinical Hypnosis, 57:3, 314-329, DOI: 10.1080/00029157.2014.976783
- Kirsch I, Montgomery G, Sapirstein G. Hypnosis as an adjunct to cognitive-behavioural psychotherapy: a meta-analysis. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1995; 63(2): 214-220.